Jump to recipe

If you’re new around here you might not know, my sisters and I take a trip together every year… no husbands, no kids, nobody but us. And although our trips (or anything else) will never be the same without Tracy, we have continued the tradition. We know it’s what she would have wanted.

Toward the end of last summer, we took our annual trip. This time, the destination was Maine! Oh, my gosh, Maine is so amazing – one of the prettiest states I’ve had the pleasure of visiting. We mostly stayed in Portland (can’t wait to go back and have Becky’s Diner clam chowder – mouthwatering!), but one day we rented a car and drove the scenic route to Bar Harbor, stopping here and there along the way, spending the day browsing small seaside towns (we loved Booth Bay Harbor), parks, cute shops, and scenic stops. One such pit-stop was a little gift shop full of quirky gifts and yummy snacks, including several varieties of fudge. Y’all, I don’t usually buy fudge from a store. It’s never been impressive. They gave free samples though, and from the first bite, I was actually impressed. I find most store-bought fudge to be grainy, and taste sort of “artificial.” I’m not going to lie to you and tell you their fudge was good as my mom’s, but it was dang good. One flavor, for me, in particular stood out… their coffee fudge. I knew I had to recreate it immediately when I got home. Well, I took a family recipe, tweaked it a bit and added some instant coffee… and dare I say it? It’s even better than the Maine gift shop’s fudge. So smooth, like a creamy candy version of a brown sugar latte. You’ll be sad when you finish the last piece of this fudge.

Oh, hey, Valentine’s Day is just around the corner! This would be the perfect homemade gift for a coffee lover…or make it for yourself! You probably won’t want to share anyway once you taste it. 😉 Erin

1 c. packed light brown sugar

1 (7.5 oz.) jar marshmallow cream

2/3 c. (5 oz. can) evaporated milk

6 T. real butter, plus more for buttering the foil

1/4 tsp. salt

1 single-serve instant dark roast coffee packet – I used Starbucks Via Instant Dark Roast.

1 (12 oz.) bag white chocolate chips – I use Ghiraridelli brand.

1 tsp. vanilla

1/2 c., plus a bit more for sprinkling on the top, English toffee bits (optional) – I used Heath Bits O’ Brickle.

Line a square pan (8″ or 9″) with foil. Evenly grease the foil with a thin coating of butter; set aside.

In a medium-sized heavy sauce pan, combine brown sugar, marshmallow cream, milk, butter, salt. When mixture is hot, but before boiling, stir in the instant coffee. Bring to a boil over medium heat. Reduce heat to a simmer, stirring constantly, for 5 minutes.

Remove from the heat. Add the white chocolate chips and stir until melted. Stir in vanilla. If desired, stir in toffee bits. Scrape into the prepared foil-lined pan and (if using) sprinkle toffee bits across the top.

Once cooled to room temp, refrigerate until firm (2-3 hours). Cut into squares and wrap in wax paper. Store in an air-tight container in the fridge.